Skip to content

SolarPunkLab · public explorer

Nederlands

What does a self-sufficient neighbourhood cost, and when does new-build beat renovation?

Eight households in Breda, the Netherlands, all-electric, with heat pumps. Set how self-sufficient the neighbourhood has to be and what seasonal storage costs per kWh. The optimisation then picks the cheapest installation that delivers it: in every one of three real weather years, not just the sunniest.

In short

  • Up to 85%, self-sufficiency is almost free. Solar panels and a community battery are enough; the energy system then costs € 277 per home per year at 70% and € 384 at 80%. Seasonal storage makes no difference there: the model does not build it yet.
  • Above that stands the winter wall. At 90% self-sufficiency the same system costs € 5,131 per home per year, including 4.8 MWh of seasonal storage. Without seasonal storage it rises to € 12,611.
  • The price of seasonal storage carries the whole conclusion. At 90% the outcome moves from € 1,600 to € 7,247 per home per year as the storage price goes from €20 to €150 per kWh. That is more than every other assumption combined.
  • The grey year 2021 sizes the neighbourhood , not sunny 2022. A neighbourhood sized on 2022 alone reaches 89.4% in 2021 instead of the promised 90%; preventing that costs € 414 per home per year.
  • The crossover year hangs on the ambition. At 70%, new-build meets renovation around 2040 under aggressive construction automation; at 90% with realistically priced seasonal storage only around 2047, and around 2053 with moderate automation.
  • The three weather years are not the harshest. Tested across fifteen weather years from 2005 to 2023, the 90% neighbourhood meets its target in 8 of the 15. The cold winter of 2010 is the real yardstick (82.9% instead of 90%) and requires more than double the seasonal store.
80%
50607080859095

Share of annual demand the neighbourhood covers itself.

Seasonal storage price€100/kWh

€20 is tank-only at industrial scale. €100 to €150 is realistic at neighbourhood scale. This is the least certain assumption in the whole model, which is why it sits on the page as a control rather than in a footnote.

Annual cost of the energy system

€384per home per year

Without seasonal storage the same ambition costs exactly the same here: the model does not build it yet. Sizing on 2022 alone would save €27 per home, but drops to 78.8% in 2018. For the whole neighbourhood of 8 homes: €3,075 per year.

The winter wall

annual cost in € per home per year · below the wall both routes are the same neighbourhood: the lines coincide

with seasonal storagebattery only
Annual cost per home against the self-sufficiency target, for two routes: with seasonal storage and battery only.from here: seasonal storage010k20k30k50%60%70%80%85%90%95%self-sufficiency targetbattery onlywith seasonal storage

Solar panels

80 kWp

10.0 kWp per home, the roof is full

Community battery

122 kWh

15 kWh per home

Seasonal storage

0

not needed at this ambition

Investment

26.8 k€ per home

244 €/m² of floor area

Does this neighbourhood make it in every weather year?

The installation is built once, but it has to get through 2018 (normal), 2021 (grey) and 2022 (record sunshine). The year with the heavy border sets the size. Alongside it sits what the same neighbourhood would reach if it had been sized on the sunniest year alone: that gap is what the robustness premium buys. Below it, the decade test: the same installation, run through fifteen weather years from 2005 to 2023.

2018
80%
this neighbourhood, built robustly
sized on 202278.8%
shortfall1.2 pp
2021sets the size
80%
this neighbourhood, built robustly
sized on 202279.2%
shortfall0.9 pp
2022
80%
this neighbourhood, built robustly
sized on 202280.1%
shortfallnone

Decade test: across 15 weather years (2005 to 2023) this installation meets the target in 6 of 15. Harshest year 2010: 73.8%.

And the crossover year: when does new-build become cheaper than renovation?

At 80% self-sufficiency the energy system costs 244 €/m². That figure enters the 60-year life-cycle comparison between new-build and deep renovation as a cost item. The higher the ambition, the heavier new-build starts, and the later the crossover year.

No automation · current building practice extended
2055
Moderate · prefab scales up cautiously
2045
Aggressive · factory-built construction breaks through
2040

Read this as a band, not a forecast. It follows from an assumed learning curve for construction automation, not from a measured trend. The three boxes are three assumptions about how fast that automation breaks through.

Every computed point at the chosen storage price
TargetWith seasonal storageBattery onlyPVBatterySeasonal storageBinding year
50%€275€27580 kWp47 kWh·2018
60%€275€27580 kWp47 kWh·2018
70%€277€27780 kWp54 kWh·2022
80%€384€38480 kWp122 kWh·2021
85%€1,809€3,46880 kWp259 kWh1.1 MWh2021
90%€5,131€12,61180 kWp262 kWh4.8 MWh2021
95%€8,475€21,84380 kWp262 kWh8.4 MWh2021

The same neighbourhood, five places in Europe

The climate ladder: exactly the same neighbourhood, with the same behaviour and the same roofs, computed at five locations between Breda and Palermo. Everything stays the same except the weather. The winter deficit is the energy storage has to bridge in winter; the amounts are net annual costs per home, robust across the three harshest weather years of that place itself, at a storage price of €100 per kWh.

Breda (NL): median winter deficit 2,686 kWh, harshest year 2010. 90% self-sufficiency costs €8,873 per home per year here, with 8.4 MWh of seasonal storage.

LocationWinter deficit (median)Harshest year70%80%90%Seasonal storage at 90%
Breda (NL)2,686 kWh2010€760€1,766€8,8738.4 MWh
Gent (BE)2,276 kWh2010€624€915€7,6707.3 MWh
München (DE)2,589 kWh2010€685€1,446€8,8408.4 MWh
Milaan (IT)694 kWh2009-€610-€564€7660.3 MWh
Palermo (IT)186 kWh2009-€58-€58-€55none

Honest footnote: this ladder runs on satellite weather (PVGIS, 2005 to 2023) with the Dutch demand profile at all five places, and uses its own, stricter yardstick than the figures above; compare locations with each other, not with the main curve. Cooling is not in the model, and south of the Alps that is exactly what becomes the real question. For Munich no usable exchange prices were available; that figure is more indicative than the others. Full method in the lab log.

What this number is not

the honesty block belongs with the model, not at the bottom of the page

  • Sized on three weather years, tested on fifteen. Sized on 2018, 2021 and 2022 at the Gilze-Rijen weather station, then tested across fifteen weather years from 2005 to 2023. That test shows the harsher year really exists: the cold winter of 2010 breaks every configuration above 70%. Decade-robust building takes more than double the seasonal store and is a different, more expensive calculation. The decade test sits below the weather-year strip for every setting.
  • Scenario euros, not a quotation. Bare technology: no fixed grid charges, no energy-tax banding, no connection fee, no subsidy. Maintenance (1 to 4% per year) and the stack reserve for the electrolyser and fuel cell are included.
  • The storage-price control is the uncertainty. Between €20 and €150 per kWh the outcome moves by more than every other assumption combined. Anyone quoting a single figure without that control is selling something.
  • Perfect foresight. The optimisation knows the entire weather year in advance. A real controller does not, and gets less out of the same installation: 88% instead of 90% with the best rule the lab has tested. Reaching 90% with such a rule anyway costs a control premium of about two fifths. See the question below.
  • Demand profile corrected (November 2026). Until November this page used the net smart-meter profile (2020 to 2022), which already lacked the solar power that households with panels use themselves, so winter weighed too heavily. With a gross profile, 90% costs € 5,131 per home per year instead of € 8,090. The wall is as steep as before; it starts four to five percentage points later. The seasonal share of the new profile has not yet been checked against measurements.
  • An annual fraction is not a PED claim. "90% self-sufficient" means 90% of the annual kWh, not self-sufficient every hour, and not the same as the Positive Energy District definition.
  • Eight households. A small neighbourhood, so little averaging. At 40 households simultaneity flattens out and the cost per home drops. That is a different calculation from this one.

Frequently asked questions

What does a self-sufficient neighbourhood cost per home per year?

That depends on two things: how self-sufficient, and what seasonal storage costs. For eight all-electric homes in Breda, the Netherlands, sized robustly across the weather years 2018, 2021 and 2022: at 70% self-sufficiency € 277 per home per year; at 80% € 384; at 90% € 5,131 with seasonal storage at €100 per kWh, and € 1,600 at €20 per kWh. These are scenario euros for bare technology: not a quotation, excluding fixed grid charges and subsidies.

Why do costs rise so steeply above 80%?

That is the winter wall. Up to roughly 85% the neighbourhood gets by on solar panels and a community battery: summer surpluses cover the daily gaps. Above it, energy has to move from summer to winter, and a day battery is the wrong tool for that. The model then builds seasonal storage (4.8 MWh at 90%), or it keeps stacking batteries. In that case 90% costs € 12,611 per home per year instead of € 5,131.

Is seasonal storage cheaper than a large battery?

Under these assumptions yes, across the whole price band tested. At 90% self-sufficiency the battery route costs € 12,611 per home per year; with seasonal storage it is € 1,600 at €20 per kWh and € 7,247 at €150 per kWh. So the direction holds, but the word "cheap" rests entirely on that price per kWh.

When does new-build become cheaper than deep renovation?

That is not a date but a function of the ambition. In this model the life-cycle costs cross around 2040 at a 70% ambition under aggressive construction automation; at 90% with realistically priced seasonal storage only around 2047 under aggressive and around 2053 under moderate automation. Without automation the curves do not cross at all before 2055 at high ambitions. This is a scenario explorer, not a forecaster: the learning curve for construction automation does not exist in the literature and is an explicit assumption here.

Which weather year determines how large the installation must be?

Within the sizing window it is 2021, the grey year, not 2018 or 2022. That is less obvious than it looks: 2018 becomes the binding year as soon as the heat pumps are taken out of the model. What matters is not annual irradiation but the deepest continuous deficit the storage has to bridge. Across the broader test of fifteen weather years the cold winter of 2010 is the harshest; it sits outside the window, and that is exactly what the decade test shows.

What does it cost to keep the promise in a bad weather year too?

The robustness premium. At 90% self-sufficiency that is € 414 per home per year on top of a neighbourhood sized on the record-sunshine year 2022 alone. Without that premium the same neighbourhood reaches 89.4% instead of 90% in the grey 2021. And that is still the generous reading, because it assumes perfect foresight.

What does 90% cost if the neighbourhood cannot see the weather coming?

More. The difference is the control premium. Every amount on this page belongs to an installation sized as if the neighbourhood knows the whole weather year in advance. A real neighbourhood controls without that knowledge. With the best rule without foresight the lab has tested, the 90% installation reaches 88.1% in the worst of the three weather years. Reaching 90% anyway takes a seasonal store of 7.0 instead of 4.8 MWh, and then 90% costs € 7,136 per home per year instead of € 5,131, at € 100 per kWh of storage. Two fifths more. With a simple rule, which draws on the store as soon as the battery is empty, 90% cannot be reached on these installations at all: it stays below 90%, even with the largest store the lab computed (89%). For a 90% promise, good control is therefore a precondition. The figure is an upper bound for the premium; control with a real weather forecast lands somewhere between the two amounts.

Does the neighbourhood hold up outside those three weather years?

Not entirely, and that is exactly what this page shows. The 90% neighbourhood is additionally tested across fifteen weather years from 2005 to 2023 and meets its target in 8 of the 15; the harshest year is 2010 at 82.9% instead of 90%. The cold winter of 2010 requires more than double the seasonal storage. Robustness is therefore a choice: which winters do you want to withstand, and that window belongs in every quotation.

How reliable are these numbers?

The physics is hard: the energy balance closes to machine precision every hour, and the optimum is a proven global optimum of a linear program, not a heuristic. The economics is soft: investment costs are market indications for 2025 and 2026, and the price of seasonal storage is explicitly labelled low-confidence. That is why it is a control. Every assumption is listed with source and confidence in the lab's public assumptions register.

Every computed point

All 35 computed configurations: per self-sufficiency target and storage price, the robust annual cost, the installation and the crossover year. Amounts in euro per home per year unless stated otherwise.

TargetStorage priceAnnual costPVBatterySeasonal storageInvestment€/m²Binding yearCrossover (aggressive)
50%€20/kWh€27580 kWp47 kWh·€23,56721420182040
50%€50/kWh€27580 kWp47 kWh·€23,56721420182040
50%€100/kWh€27580 kWp47 kWh·€23,56721420182040
50%€150/kWh€27580 kWp47 kWh·€23,56721420182040
60%€20/kWh€27580 kWp47 kWh·€23,56721420182040
60%€50/kWh€27580 kWp47 kWh·€23,56721420182040
60%€100/kWh€27580 kWp47 kWh·€23,56721420182040
60%€150/kWh€27580 kWp47 kWh·€23,56721420182040
70%€20/kWh€27780 kWp54 kWh·€23,87021720222040
70%€50/kWh€27780 kWp54 kWh·€23,87021720222040
70%€100/kWh€27780 kWp54 kWh·€23,87021720222040
70%€150/kWh€27780 kWp54 kWh·€23,87021720222040
80%€20/kWh€38480 kWp122 kWh·€26,84324420212040
80%€50/kWh€38480 kWp122 kWh·€26,84324420212040
80%€100/kWh€38480 kWp122 kWh·€26,84324420212040
80%€150/kWh€38480 kWp122 kWh·€26,84324420212040
85%€20/kWh€88880 kWp178 kWh1.8 MWh€34,09231020212041
85%€50/kWh€1,28780 kWp227 kWh1.3 MWh€39,81236220212042
85%€100/kWh€1,80980 kWp259 kWh1.1 MWh€47,08142820212043
85%€150/kWh€2,30580 kWp259 kWh1.1 MWh€54,06049220182043
90%€20/kWh€1,60080 kWp169 kWh5.5 MWh€43,47439520212042
90%€50/kWh€2,97980 kWp215 kWh5.0 MWh€63,06957320212044
90%€100/kWh€5,13180 kWp262 kWh4.8 MWh€93,24684820212047
90%€150/kWh€7,24780 kWp267 kWh4.8 MWh€123,0291,11820212050
95%€20/kWh€2,33080 kWp159 kWh9.3 MWh€53,01348220212043
95%€50/kWh€4,69180 kWp215 kWh8.7 MWh€86,48778620212047
95%€100/kWh€8,47580 kWp262 kWh8.4 MWh€139,6221,26920212051
95%€150/kWh€12,22080 kWp267 kWh8.4 MWh€192,3361,74920212055
50%Without seasonal storage (battery only)€27580 kWp47 kWh·€23,56721420182040
60%·€27580 kWp47 kWh·€23,56721420182040
70%·€27780 kWp54 kWh·€23,87021720222040
80%·€38480 kWp122 kWh·€26,84324420212040
85%·€3,46880 kWp912 kWh·€61,40455820182044
90%·€12,61180 kWp3,051 kWh·€154,9811,40920212053
95%·€21,84380 kWp5,198 kWh·€248,9152,2632021·

The full dataset as JSON · the decade test as JSON · CC BY 4.0

How this was computed

Each point is a single linear program over the concatenated weather years 2018, 2021 and 2022, 26,280 hours in total, with shared capacity variables: the neighbourhood is built once and has to get through every weather year. The self-sufficiency constraint applies per year, not on average. Solved with PyPSA and HiGHS; the energy balance closes to machine precision every hour. Weather: Dutch met office (KNMI) station 350, Gilze-Rijen. Demand profile: MFFBAS E1A 2015, the last vintage in which few households had solar panels; newer profiles are net and would count the neighbourhood’s own solar power twice. Prices: ENTSO-E day-ahead Netherlands. Net metering is switched off: this is an investment question for 2027 and beyond. In addition, every configuration shown is tested with fixed capacities across fifteen weather years from 2005 to 2023, the decade test below the weather-year strip.

Weather: KNMI-350 (2018, 2021, 2022) · demand profile: MFFBAS E1A 2015 (gross) · prices: ENTSO-E day-ahead NL · scenario basis-8-warmte 1.1.0, assumptions A1–A81 + K1–K8 · computed 2026-11-11 with a linear program (PyPSA/HiGHS) over 26,280 hours · decade test 2026-11-11 across 15 weather years (2005 to 2023)